No. 214 · 6 minute read
Salary or draw: what to pay yourself when profit is lumpy
Dear owner, last spring a reader asked me a question I hear every month: “I made money this year, so why does paying myself feel like robbing the business?”
Mara Quint kept the books for 63 small businesses over eleven years. Now she writes to 11,400 owners about cash, pricing and paying yourself, with the arithmetic shown. The letter is free. The worksheet that comes with it costs $9 a month.
Free, and every letter has a one-click unsubscribe. Not sure yet? Read three recent letters first
This is the inbox a subscriber sees. The letter is the free part. The section underneath it is what paid readers get, and we have blurred the real text and written down exactly what is under it.
Letters run 1,000 to 1,400 words. Paid sections add 500 to 700 more, plus a sheet you can download.
Dear owner, a reader who runs a two-person design studio wrote to ask why paying herself feels like robbing the business, even in a year when the business made money.
Here is what I see in almost every set of books: the owner pays from the bank balance on the day they feel brave. Good month, big transfer. Quiet month, nothing. The business never knows what it owes you, and you never know what you earn.
The fix is a floor and a top-up. The floor is a fixed monthly amount the business can pay you even in its worst quarter. The top-up is a share of whatever comes in above the floor, paid once a quarter, after the quarter is closed. Salary or draw is a tax question that depends on how your business is set up, and your accountant should answer it. The floor and top-up work under either.
The floor worked out for that studio from twelve real months of profit, a five-row quarter table, and the rule for when the top-up should be zero.
About 560 words, one table, one downloadable sheet.
Dear owner, a landscaping company I worked with had a good March on paper: more came in than went out. They still bounced a payroll on the twelfth.
Monthly numbers hide the order money moves in. Customers pay in the first week, your payroll and the van loan both leave in the second, and the quarterly tax estimate lands in the fourth. Add up the month and it looks fine. Live through the second week and it does not.
So look at cash one week at a time, thirteen weeks ahead. It takes about forty minutes the first time and ten minutes each Monday after that. You are looking for one thing: the weeks where the balance dips lowest, so you can move a bill, chase an invoice or hold off a purchase before you get there.
Five weeks of that company's cash, week by week, with the two weeks where payroll collides with a loan or a tax payment marked, and the one change that fixed it.
About 610 words, one table, a 13-week sheet to copy.
Dear owner, a contractor quoted a kitchen in January, the supplier raised prices before the work started, and he asked me whether an 18% rise in materials was worth an awkward phone call.
It almost always is, because the rise does not come out of the price. It comes out of your margin, and your margin is a much smaller number. A materials bill that is 40% of a job, going up 18%, takes about half of a 15% margin.
Customers take a re-quote better than owners expect, if three things are true: you call before the work starts, you show the supplier's new price, and you offer one way to keep the old total, such as a cheaper finish. Below is the call, and the arithmetic you should do before making it.
That kitchen job costed line by line, the price that keeps a 15% margin after the increase, and the four-sentence script he used on the phone.
About 520 words, one table, the script as a text file.
Everyone gets the letter. Paying gets you the worked numbers underneath it, the archive, and a monthly checklist. If the letter is all you need, stay free; plenty of readers do.
For owners who want the thinking and are happy to do their own arithmetic.
For owners who would rather copy a filled-in sheet than build one from a paragraph.
Stock or crypto tips, sponsored software recommendations, and advice on your own tax return. Mara is a bookkeeper writing to a crowd; for your specific filing, pay an accountant who has seen your books.
There are 50 letters a year; we take the last week of December and one week in August off. Tell us how long you'd stay and how many letters you would really read, and the ledger works out the price of each one you read.
Be honest. Most paid readers open three in four.
| Over 12 months | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| You pay | $108 | $90 |
| Letters delivered | 50 | 50 |
| Letters you read | 50 | 50 |
| Per letter read | $2.16 | $1.80 |
You'd pay $18 less over 12 months.
Annual is paid up front and refundable in full for the first 30 days, then not at all. Monthly cancels at the end of the month you're in. Prices are in US dollars; your card converts them. Read every letter for a year and the paid edition costs $2.16 a letter monthly or $1.80 annually, The two cost the same at ten months; from the eleventh, annual is cheaper.
I kept the books for 63 small businesses between 2012 and 2023: a bakery, a nine-person plumbing firm, two dental practices, a lot of studios and a surprising number of dog groomers. Most of them were profitable. Most of them still felt broke on the fifteenth.
I started the letter to answer the same questions once instead of sixty times. Every Ledger section uses numbers from a real business, changed enough that the owner can't be recognised and with their permission.
Readers write back every week. These four arrived last quarter, printed with permission.
“The thirteen-week sheet found the week we'd have missed payroll in November. We moved the equipment lease date with one phone call. That single letter has paid for the year about eight times over.”
Priya N., physiotherapy clinic, Leeds. Paid, annual
“I've read it free for two years. The letters alone made me raise my prices twice. I don't need the sheets; I like doing the sums myself.”
Tomás R., furniture restorer, Valencia. Free
“Issue 198 on deposits was the clearest thing I've read on the subject, and I'm an accountant. I send clients the free link now.”
Hannah L., sole-practitioner accountant, Toronto. Paid, monthly
“Your tax calendar covers four countries and I live in a fifth. A quarter of the paid edition is useless to me in New Zealand and I'm paying full price for it.”
Grant W., café owner, Wellington. Paid, monthly
Mara's reply: That's fair. I won't add New Zealand until an accountant there has checked every date, and I don't have one yet. Until then, monthly is the right plan for you, not annual.
Anything else, write to mara@ledgerline.example. A person answers, usually Mara.
The letters are about cash, pricing and pay, which work the same way anywhere. Examples are in dollars and pounds. Only the tax-date calendar is country-specific, and it covers the US, UK, Canada and Australia.
Yes, at any time. The month you've already paid for is taken off the annual price, so you never pay twice for the same weeks.
Monthly stops at the end of the month you cancel in. Annual is refunded in full if you cancel within 30 days; after that it runs to the end of the year and isn't refunded. If you aren't sure you'll stay ten months, pay monthly.
Every payment comes with a receipt that carries your business name and tax number if you add them. Whether it's deductible where you are is a question for your accountant.
No. The list is used to send the letter and nothing else. There are no sponsors and no partner offers.
Forward the free letter to anyone you like. For the paid edition, a second reader at the same business is $4 a month extra; reply to your welcome email to add them.
Start free. You can move to the paid edition from any letter, and back again, without talking to anyone.