Bring a contact sheet. Leave knowing which frame to print.

The Darkroom Collective is an online community for people who shoot film. Twice a month we put members' negatives on screen and talk through them, frame by frame. Between critiques there is a library of 64 guides and a forum where someone has already answered your question about HC-110 dilutions.

Free membership covers the forum, one live critique a month and two guides. Paid tiers start at $7 a month, billed yearly.

A contact sheet of four film strips. One frame is circled in red grease pencil, another is crossed out, with a note to print frame 14 at 8 by 10.
Roll 31 from a member's first critiqueprint this one

What a month here looks like

The calendar repeats every month, so you can plan a roll around it. Times are UTC; the two critiques sit twelve hours apart so members in Melbourne and in Montreal each get one at a sane hour.

  1. First Tuesday19:00 UTC, 90 minutes

    Members' critique

    Twelve frames from the submission queue, about seven minutes each. You hear what works, what to burn in, and whether the problem is the negative or the print. Paid members only, recorded for anyone who misses it.

    Led by Ines Albrecht or Tomás Reyes, alternating
  2. Second weekPublished on the Monday

    A new guide

    One per month, written by whoever knows the subject best. Last month was pushing Tri-X two stops without losing the shadows; next month is scanning colour negatives without the orange cast.

    Guides run 2,500 to 6,000 words with test strips
  3. Third Saturday07:00 UTC, 60 minutes

    Open critique

    Shorter, and anyone with a free account can watch live. Eight frames, chosen from the forum's monthly assignment thread. This is the one to try before paying for anything.

    Led by Grace Okafor
  4. All monthCloses on the last day

    The roll of the month

    A brief posted in the forum: one roll, one constraint. October's was "a single 50mm lens, only after sunset." Members post their contact sheets and the best eight go to the open critique.

    Around 140 sheets posted each month

A thread and a shelf, as members see them

Below is a real-shaped critique thread from the forum and the newest part of the guide index. Names are shown with permission; members can post under initials if they prefer.

Critique requests / Portrait by a north window, HP5 at 80014 replies

Mira K. · Print member

First roll pushed a stop. Shot at 1/60, f/2.8, developed in DD-X for 9:30. The face looks muddy to me on the scan, but the negative looks fine on the light box. Is it the push or my scanning?

The posted portrait: a figure lit from a window on the right, with red grease-pencil marks around the window and an arrow to the jaw
Frame 13A, marked up by the tutor

Ines AlbrechtTutor

The negative is fine. You are scanning for the window, so the face sits low on the curve. Rescan exposed for the cheek, let the window clip, and dodge the jaw by about a third of a stop. I circled it on your frame. This one goes in Tuesday's queue if you want it talked through.

Dan O. · Free member

Same thing happened to me with Portra. Guide 59 has the scanner settings that fixed it.

Guide index, newest first

64 guides so far. Free members choose any two a month; paid members read all of them.

  1. Pushing Tri-X two stops18 min
  2. Making a split-grade print24 min
  3. Reading a negative on a light box11 min
  4. Stand development, and when it lies16 min
  5. Metering for shadows with a phone9 min
  6. Scanning colour without the orange21 min
  7. Mixing your own fixer13 min
  8. Choosing a first medium format camera27 min

Membership

The tiers are named after what you'd be doing at each level. Prices are in US dollars, tax included where your country requires it.

Yearly costs less from your tenth month onward.

fits your month
4×6, a proof print

Proof

$0forever

No card needed

  • The forum, reading and posting
  • Watch the open critique live, once a month
  • Any two guides a month
  • Enter the roll of the month
  • Your own frames critiqued
  • Recordings and the full library
Join free
fits your month
8×10, the print you hang

Print

$9a month

Billed monthly, cancel any time

  • Everything in Proof
  • Both live critiques, plus recordings
  • One frame a month critiqued aloud
  • All 64 guides and every new one
  • Members-only darkroom chemistry threads
  • Written portfolio reviews
Choose Print
fits your month
11×14, for the wall at a show

Exhibition

$19a month

Billed monthly, cancel any time

  • Everything in Print
  • Three frames a month critiqued aloud
  • A written portfolio review every quarter: 12 frames, about 800 words, from one tutor
  • The quarterly print exchange: post one print, receive one from another member
Choose Exhibition

Need one portfolio review and nothing else? Anyone, including free members, can buy a single written review for $35. If you would want fewer than three a year, that is cheaper than Exhibition. Not sure which you need? Answer five questions below and the tier that fits gets circled here.

What would you actually use?

Most people overestimate how many critiques they will attend. Set these to an ordinary month, not your best one, and we will tell you the cheapest way to get it. Sometimes that is the free tier.

Live critiques you'd attend 1 Out of two a month. Watching the recording counts.
Your frames critiqued, per month 0 Frames you submit to be talked through on screen.
Read all the way through, not opened and saved for later.
Twelve frames, read and written up by a tutor.
Decides whether monthly or yearly billing is cheaper.

For an ordinary month like that

Proof, free

$0 a month

You would watch the open critique and read two guides, which the free tier already covers.

Each way of paying, over 6 months

Join free

The three people who read your negatives

They are paid from membership fees and they disagree with each other often, which is half the value of the critiques.

Ines Albrecht

Leipzig · Rolleiflex 2.8F, HP5, fibre prints

Printed for a commercial lab for eleven years before teaching. Leads the Tuesday critiques in alternate months and writes most of the printing guides.

"Fix it in the negative if you can, in the print if you must."

Tomás Reyes

Mexico City · Nikon FM2, Portra 400, scanned

Street and documentary work, almost all colour. The person to ask about scanning, colour casts and whether a frame is worth reprinting at all.

"Fewer frames. Take the one you were walking towards."

Grace Okafor

Manchester · Pentax 67, Delta 100, darkroom at home

Runs the Saturday open critique and the roll of the month. Built her darkroom in a spare bathroom and wrote the guide on doing the same for under $300.

"Show me the whole sheet, not the one you like."

From members, including one who left

"I had been shooting for four years and printing nothing. Ines picked one frame off my first sheet and told me how to print it. It is above my desk now, and I have printed thirty since."
Hana Sato, Print member since 2024, Osaka
"The forum alone was worth it. I stayed on the free tier for a year before I had anything I wanted critiqued."
Ben Hollis, Proof, then Print, Leeds
"I cancelled Exhibition. The written reviews were excellent but I only had enough work for two a year, so I was paying for four."
Priya Raman, former Exhibition member, Toronto

That complaint is why the single $35 review exists, and why the estimator above recommends it.

Questions people ask before joining

Anything else, write to hello@darkroomcollective.example. Grace answers most of them.

No. About half of the members scan their negatives and never print in a darkroom. Critiques cover the negative first, then whichever way you finish it: scan, wet print or lab print.

Upload a scan of the frame and, if you have one, the contact sheet it came from. Paid members get a guaranteed slot in the next critique for each frame in their monthly allowance. Unused allowance does not roll over.

Yes, any time. Moving up starts the new tier immediately and charges the difference for the rest of the period. Moving down takes effect at the end of what you have paid for.

Within the first 30 days, we refund all of it. After that, we refund the unused whole months minus the yearly discount you received, so leaving yearly is never better than having paid monthly.

Both, and the critiques are better for the mix. About a third of members have been shooting film for less than two years. If you have never loaded a roll, start with guide 3, "Loading and developing a first roll", which is open to everyone.

Join the collective

Free members get access straight away. For Print or Exhibition we email a payment link with your first invoice, and nothing is charged until you open it.

  • 3,140 members in 41 countries
  • Next open critique: the third Saturday, 07:00 UTC
  • Refund in full within 30 days on any paid tier

We use your email for membership and the monthly calendar only. Unsubscribe from the calendar in one click; your account stays.