Cartographer’s ChestBoard games and puzzles, Toronto

Every game on our shelf comes with a note on what it’s bad at.

We’re a board game and puzzle shop on Dundas Street West. We play everything at least five times before stocking it, so when a game falls flat with two players or drags with four beginners, the shelf label says so and so does the product page.

How many of you are playing?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7+
A hex-tile map with red, blue and yellow meeples, two dice and a face-down card

The shelf label prints what the box leaves out

A box tells you the player range and an optimistic play time. Our labels add the three things you actually need to decide.

  • The best player count“2–4 players” means the rules work at two. It doesn’t mean the game is good at two.
  • A weight from 1 to 5How much there is to learn. Under 1.8 you can teach it in five minutes; over 3 plan on half an hour.
  • One honest “bad at” lineThe group, the evening or the person it doesn’t suit. Staff write it after their fifth game, not their first.

Tidewright

Saltmarsh Games. Harbours on a hex coast; the tide moves every third round.
3.1weight
2–4 players 60–90 min Ages 12+
Best at
Three players. The coast fills up and every tide hurts somebody.
Good for
Groups who like planning ahead and don’t mind having the plan ruined.
Bad at
A first game with four new players runs close to two hours. Teach it at three if you can.
Instead
Only two of you? Two Rivers was written for exactly that.

On the front table this week

The boxes staff keep pulling off the shelf for people. Each product page has its “bad at” line in the description.

How heavy is heavy?

Weight is our rating of how much there is to learn and hold in your head, from 1 (explain it while shuffling) to 5 (read the rulebook the night before). It isn’t a quality score. Barnstorm at 1.6 gets played more often in this shop than anything above 3.

The game finder lets you ask for light, medium or heavy, and tells you when a match is heavier than you asked for.

Find a game by weight

New on the shelf

Arrived in the last few weeks and already played five times by staff, which is the rule before anything gets a label.

A 1000-piece puzzle is about twelve hours of your evenings

That’s at 85 pieces an hour, the pace of someone who does a few a year. The bigger question is usually the table: a puzzle needs its finished size plus room to sort, for as long as it takes you.

PiecesFinished sizeHours at 85/h
50049 × 36 cmabout 6
100069 × 49 cmabout 12
150085 × 60 cmabout 18
A half-finished jigsaw with two pieces missing
A game in progress on a table in front of the shop's shelves

Play it at the shop before you buy it

Our library has 140 open games, including every one on the shelf rated 3.5 or heavier. Come in any afternoon and take one to a table, or come on Thursday when staff teach whatever you pull off the wall.

Thursdays, 18:00–23:00Table night. Free, no booking for groups under six.
Tuesday to Sunday11:00–20:00 at 1188 Dundas Street West.
Visiting, shipping and returns